If the notion that “culture shapes
education, and education shapes culture,” (Wadham, Pudsey, Boyd) is accepted,
it is clear that one’s schooling experience directly impacts their
understanding of both their own heritage, as well other’s backgrounds, and
largely influences their definition of self. My experience has changed
drastically in the level of multiculturalism between my school and UNSW and
therefore, with the transition to tertiary education has come a large change in
my grasp and definition of culture and identity in relation to education.
From age three I attended a co-educational,
independent private school in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs. The school was a modern
orthodox Jewish school and therefore as well as secular subjects, up to
the end of grade ten, extra subjects were compulsory, including jewish studies,
jewish history and Hebrew language studies. With no differentiation in the
religion one followed – students were only accepted if both their parents were
of jewish faith, or at minimum, their mother was jewish – one’s religious
cultural identity was somewhat formed from as early on as pre-school.
Unlike many schools where despite the cohort
being of singular religious faith, their familial backgrounds produce an
element of multiculturalism, the student population of my school was relatively
limited to those of either South African or European descent, especially
Eastern European. A number of the South African students were themselves
migrants to Australia, whilst many of European descent were either first or
second generation Australians. This is easily justified as one considers the
atrocities in Europe that faced our grandparent’s generation, namely the
Holocaust, and the wave of immigration to Australia as a consequence of this. I
myself am a second generation Australian of Hungarian roots on my maternal
side. I also, however, have lineage dating back to the first fleet on my
paternal side. Despite the fact that I identify myself as Australian, I
definitely think that my experience at a Jewish school, and especially the
in-depth studies into modern Jewish history such as the Holocaust, has informed
my decision to always add “but my family is Hungarian” to my definition of
cultural background and nationality.
Whilst the school I attended had many of
migrant backgrounds, or students who were ‘new Aussies,’ cultural diversity
remained somewhat limited. My graduating class of 132 students had one Eurasian
student and 131 Caucasian students. The indigenous population of my school was
0% and the socio-economic background of students ranged from average,
comfortable Australians (like myself) to some of Australia’s richest. All
students who finished in my year lived within suburbs of each other with no one
really living beyond the 'bubble' of suburbs between Vaucluse and Randwick.
What remained in common amongst students, teachers and parents alike was the
high standards of education expected at the school, and the high expectations
in relation to ATARS, with the school pushing to achieve as many over 90 and
higher as possible. Perhaps the greatest similarity, however, was the
overwhelming feeling of being part of a very close-knit community, something
which I am told is not a part of every school's culture. The school was
essentially a microcosm of the community it served.
Here I refer to Eagleton's definition, "'Culture'
is said to be one of the...most complex words in the English language, and the
term which is sometimes considered to be its opposite - nature - is commonly
awarded the accolade of being the most complex of all. Yet though it is
fashionable these days to see nature as a derivative of culture, culture, etymologically
speaking, is a concept derived from nature." In my opinion, this
essentially echoes Wadham, Pudsey & Boyd's sentiments included earlier in
the piece and furthers this definition to include the equally relevant cycle of
culture to nature. My understanding of my religiosity derived directly from the
nature of the school I attended, which was aimed at honing in on
one's cultural heritage and finding relevance to one's culture within modern
day life. The same is now true of my experiences at university, whereby the
nature of the educational institution informs a culture of acceptance,
diversity and esteem.
Thus far, university, obviously, has
introduced me to a whole new level of multiculturalism as it has proven to be a
melting pot of varying cultures.. In regards to cultural lineage, a major
change of note has been the drastic change in percentage of Caucasian to Asian
students – remembering that my graduating class was 99% Caucasian.
That “education shapes culture and culture
shapes education” is somewhat undeniable. In my experience, where religion
informed your choice of school, my school informed me of my religion. The
close-knit jewish community of the eastern suburbs also played a large role,
both in relation to the so-called ‘pressures’ to achieve high results from
students and also in the feeling that we were part of a large school
“Family" – again, an example of the interrelatedness between culture and
education. And now that my educational environment is so much more diverse, I
cannot wait to experience how my definition of personal identity and culture
will change over the next years.
By Carly Fisher
References:
Wadham, B, Pudsey, J & Boyd, R. 'Culture
and Education' - Pearson, Education Australia
Eagleton,
T. 'The Idea of Culture' - Blackwell - Oxford, UK. 2000
Hi Carly,
ReplyDeleteYour draft post regarding your educational experiences was very informative. I found that by attending a religious based schools you have indeed had quite a different experience.Whilst I found that Wadham, Pudsey and Boyd was very applicable to your experience I feel that maybe if you were to review Phillips and Vass readings they would be able to add some significant support to your perceptions on culture. Your concise analysis of the educational scape in which you attended was both informative and interesting, and I enjoyed the conversational tone. Good job.